Slumdog’s controversies

Country is into a big controversy now, “Slumdog Millionare” controversy! Some people says its a great film, will win many awards (especially oscars) etc etc; while some people say’s Slumdog is just a crap film made by the west to spit their sarcasm on the Indian faces. This is something worth writing, I believe.
Well, as a movie based on a fiction novel “Q&A” by Vikas Swaroop (an Indian Strategeist on foreign affairs), I liked it. I liked it as a good movie, well written, well executed, well made music and some interesting performances especially by the kid who played “Jamal Malik” as a child, also as teen by Dev Patel. Movie is well directed by English director Danny Boyle and has a well written screenplay by Simon Beufoy.
But I dont think this movie is worth for its 10 oscar nominations. Though this movies falls into a “good” category, its not sth great! A.R Rahman deserves one for music (its simply superb, I dunno much abt western music though!) and the rest all are okay okay types. I found the direction of hindhi film “Rang De Basanthi” and its plot more praiseworthy than Slumdog Millionare.
So the question is, is slumdog millionare just a spit of western sarcasm and arrogance ?
Amithab Bachan said like this:
http://bigb.bigadda.com/2009/01/25/day-276/
See the one from Arindam Choudary:
http://arindamchaudhuri.blogspot.com/2009/01/dont-see-slumdog-millionaire-it-sucks.html
Guys above say’s Slumdog people have not portrayed the “actual” India in this movie, which is vibrant, 5-star, with billionares and billionares!! or in short, Slumdog Millionare is just a western shit and a satisfaction of their racial dominancy feel.
On the other side, people like Irfan Khan, Anil Kapoor etc said, “Slumdog millionare speaks about facts in India, there is such a condition that exists”
Irfan Khan also said to CNN that “afterall its just a drama movie!” , well I agree with that 100%. Why so much noises on that?
We also can make one movie portraying the british “fancies” or the “funny” western life, if we want!!…lol!!
Fact is that India has 5 classes of people living here.
Taking a specimen of Mumbai, you will find
1. The low-end people (who lives in slums, one bedroom flats, one rooms etc)
2. The lower-middle class people ( who lives in flats with rent Rs.8000 and above)
3. The middle class people (who lives in the Rs. 15 to 20K range)
4. The upper middle class ( who lives in 30 to 40K range)
5. High Class people ( who lives in luxury)
Afterall the guys who produced this movie, directory Dany Boyle, actors Anil Kapoor, Irfan Khan, musical maestro A.R. Rahman, writer Vikas Swaroop and most of the Slumdog Millionare crew represents the categoey “HIGH CLASS” who lives in luxury!
Now the ones who raised voice against the movie, Amithab Bachan and Arindam Choudary also represents the same.
Now only one question!!
are these guys willing to spend atleast 1% of their total income for the welfare of backward Indians?
Projecting out the Indian slum, producers of movie might have grabbed millions of dollars and will they spend atleast 1 million dollar ? or even a 100$ ??
The “Big” people are worried…some says there are slums…some says there are not!!…while the actual slums remains happy (with what they have and what they love)!!…they might not even know about such a crap going on around!
share your views!


About me! what to say...